Gravitational wave astronomy has made black holes accessible to scientific scrutiny. However, a puzzling dissonance in the gravitational wave signals emitted by black holes after mergers, known as ringdown signals, has challenged physicists for many years. A recent breakthrough by Associate Professor Hayato Motohashi of Tokyo Metropolitan University has resolved this longstanding mystery, providing new understandings of black hole behavior and reinforcing the predictions of General Relativity. 1
Image Credit: Dabarti CGI/Shutterstock.com
Background of the Black Hole Ringdown and the Dissonance Problem
Gravitational waves are ripples in spacetime caused by massive bodies such as colliding black holes. When two black holes merge, they form a larger, distorted black hole that gradually settles into a stable state. This settling phase emits gravitational waves with characteristic frequencies. This process is called the ringdown, because physicists compare it to the way a bell rings after being struck. Like a bell that vibrates and gradually quiets down, a disturbed black hole gives off gravitational waves that slowly fade as it settles back into a stable state. 2
Physicists model these ringdown signals as a superposition of quasinormal modes. These modes are expected to vary smoothly and predictably. However, since the late 1990s, calculations have identified a mysterious irregularity. One particular mode exhibited behavior inconsistent with the rest. This phenomenon is known as "dissonance" in black hole ringdown signals. 3
This dissonance challenged the analogy of black holes ringing like bells and raised questions about the completeness of the theoretical models. Early suspicions pointed to computational errors or artifacts, but even with advances in numerical relativity and improved computational power, the mismatch persisted, representing a gap in understanding black hole vibrations.
No time to read now? Download your PDF copy here.
Resolving the Dissonance Through Mode Resonance
A 2025 study closed a long-standing gap in understanding black hole vibrations by using high-precision numerical simulations alongside a new theoretical framework based on non-Hermitian physics.
The researchers discovered, by examining the interactions among multiple oscillation modes, that the dissonance was not an isolated anomaly but the result of resonance between two distinct modes of the black hole.
This resonance causes the modes to influence each other's frequencies and damping rates, producing the previously unexplained irregularity in the ringdown signal. Moreover, this mode interaction phenomenon is not rare but appears to be a universal feature across a range of black hole oscillation modes. The study demonstrated that these resonances are analogous to phenomena observed in other physical systems, such as electromagnetic wave interactions in optical physics. 1, 3
These findings of this study led to the establishment of a new subfield dubbed non-Hermitian gravitational physics, which extends traditional linear perturbation theory by incorporating mode coupling and nonlinear effects. The refined models now accurately reproduce the gravitational wave frequencies observed in black hole mergers, effectively making the black holes "ring true" to Einstein's General Relativity. 1, 3, 4
Methodological Advances Behind the Discovery
The resolution of the dissonance problem was achieved through a combination of advanced numerical relativity simulations and sophisticated waveform analysis. The researchers’ approach involved breaking down gravitational wave signals into their individual quasinormal modes and analyzing their frequency spectra with high precision. 1, 3
The application of non-Hermitian physics concepts allowed the modeling of mode resonance and energy exchange between modes (these effects were neglected in earlier linear perturbation models). These theoretical models were supported by high-performance computing resources at Tokyo Metropolitan University, enabling simulations that captured subtle nonlinear interactions during the ringdown phase. The findings of this research were published in the journal Physical Review Letters in April 2025. 1, 3
Implications for Gravitational Wave Astronomy and Black Hole Physics
This study has great implications for the field of gravitational wave astronomy. Accurate modeling of ringdown signals is crucial for extracting precise parameters of black holes, such as their mass and spin, from observational data. The improved theoretical framework enhances the reliability of these measurements and improves the understanding of black hole populations and their formation histories.
Moreover, the ability to detect and interpret multiple oscillation modes strengthens the testing of General Relativity in the strong-field regime. Observations from detectors like LIGO, Virgo, and KAGRA, as well as next-generation space-based observatories such as LISA, rely on precise waveform models to identify potential deviations from Einstein's theory. The new model's success in explaining the dissonance reaffirms confidence in General Relativity.1, 3, 5
Future Directions
The resolution of the dissonance issue invites further exploration into nonlinear and multi-mode effects in gravitational wave signals. There is also a possibility of extending these analyses to other compact objects, such as neutron stars' mergers or exotic objects beyond standard black holes. Understanding whether similar mode interactions or resonances occur in these systems could provide crucial information about their internal structure and the physics of dense matter.
Moreover, ongoing debates around the detectability of overtones highlight the importance of continually improving data analysis methods and noise modeling in gravitational wave detectors. 6
References and Further Reading
- Motohashi, H. (2025). Resonant excitation of quasinormal modes of black holes. Physical Review Letters. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.134.141401
- Schmidt, P. (2020). Gravitational waves from binary black hole mergers: Modeling and observations. Frontiers in Astronomy and Space Sciences. https://doi.org/10.3389/fspas.2020.00028
- Tokyo Metropolitan University (2025) 30-year mystery of dissonance in the 'ringing' of black holes explained. Phys.org. https://phys.org/news/2025-04-year-mystery-dissonance-black-holes.html
- For whom the black hole rings (2023) Observation of multiple ringdown modes in a black hole merger. Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics press release. https://www.mpg.de/21047683/observation-of-two-frequencies-in-ringdown-gravitational-wave-signal
- Scientists Detect Black Hole Ringing “Like a Bell” (2019) Stonny Brook Matters. https://sbmatters.stonybrook.edu/scientists-detect-black-hole-ringing-like-a-bell/
- R. Cotesta et al. (2022) Analysis of ringdown overtones in GW150914. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.129.111102
Disclaimer: The views expressed here are those of the author expressed in their private capacity and do not necessarily represent the views of AZoM.com Limited T/A AZoNetwork the owner and operator of this website. This disclaimer forms part of the Terms and conditions of use of this website.